Engle, M. (2008). The surrender
tree: Poems of Cuba's struggle for freedom. New York: Henry Holt and
Company.
Freedom
is something that she has yet to be given in the three wars that Cuba faced in
the late 1800’s. Rosa is a nurse who hides in the forest of Cuba and heals the
wounds of the people, both local and opposing slave hunters and soldiers. She
even heals the one soldier who is out to find, kill and claim the bounty for
her. Through the poetic verses, Rosa cures who she can and fights the battle of
illness from one patient to the next hoping for the better in the end.
Margarita
Engle tells the story of a slave, Rosa, who lives to help and heal the sick. As
a Cuban American poet, Engle gives the reader several point of views from being
the slave and helping defeat the war, to the opposing side of those initiating
the war, to one who a escapes Cuba with a hope of paradise in the future. The
short stanzas are easy to read and can be discussed individually and the reader
can vividly imagine each character and the forest of Cuba. Engle does a
fantastic job providing such imagery and simplicity in text for young readers
through the free verse poems.
I
enjoyed this book of poems. The simplistic reading made it flow from one
character to another and one event to another. I wan able to focus on what Rosa
was doing and see points of views of those who cared for her and what they did
for her. I also saw what hatred and greed did to others, such as Lieutenant
Death. These poems would be a great way to present the wars in Cuba and conduct
research on what caused those wars and provide insight of both sides of the
war. The book provides a chronological timeline of events that students can use
to assist them in their reading of the free verse poems.
Reviews
School
Library Journal
Grade
9 Up—Often, popular knowledge of Cuba begins and ends with late-20th-century
textbook fare: the Cuban Revolution, the Cuban Missile Crisis, and Fidel
Castro. The Surrender Tree, however, transports readers to another,
though no less tumultuous, era. Spanning the years 1850–1899, Engle's poems
construct a narrative woven around the nation's Wars for Independence. The
poems are told in alternating voices, though predominantly by Rosa, a
"freed" slave and natural healer destined to a life on the lam in the
island' s wild interior. Other narrators include Teniente Muerte, or
Lieutenant Death, the son of a slave hunter turned ruthless soldier; José,
Rosa's husband and partner in healing; and Silvia, an escapee from one of
Cuba's reconcentration camps. The Surrender Tree is hauntingly
beautiful, revealing pieces of Cuba's troubled past through the poetry of
hidden moments such as the glimpse of a woman shuttling children through a cave
roof for Rosa's care or the snapshot of runaway Chinese slaves catching a
crocodile to eat. Though the narrative feels somewhat repetitive in its first
third, one comes to realize it is merely symbolic of the unending cycle of war
and the necessity for Rosa and other freed slaves to flee domesticity each time
a new conflict begins. Aside from its considerable stand-alone merit, this
book, when paired with Engle's The Poet Slave of Cuba: A Biography of Juan
Francisco Manzano (Holt, 2006), delivers endless possibilities for
discussion about poetry, colonialism, slavery, and American foreign policy.—Jill
Heritage Maza, Greenwich High School, CT
Booklist
*Starred
Review* As in The Poet Slave of Cuba (2006), Engle’s new book is written in
clear, short lines of stirring free verse. This time she draws on her own Cuban
American roots, including stories from her grandmother, to describe those who
fought in the nineteenth-century Cuban struggle for independence. At the center
is Rosa, a traditional healer, who nurses runaway slaves and deserters in caves
and other secret hideaways. Her husband, José, a freed slave, also speaks, and
so does a refugee child, whom Rosa teaches to be a healer. Then there
is the vicious slave hunter known as Lieutenant Death; his collection of
ears is an unforgettable image of brutality (“shown as proof that the runaway
slave / died fighting, resisting capture”). The switching perspectives
personalize the dramatic political history, including the establishment of the
world’s first “reconcentration camps” to hold prisoners, as well as the role of
slave owners who freed their slaves and joined the resistance against Spain.
Many readers will be caught by the compelling narrative voices and want to
pursue the historical accounts in Engle’s bibliography. Grades 6-12. --Hazel
Rochman